There are different versions of what happened next but the end result was the same-she died. One version has her saying "So here it is," and removing the figs to reveal the snake, and holding out her arm to be bitten. Another has her provoking the asp to anger with a golden spindle until it jumped out of a jar and bit her. She was 39. Plutarch tells us that she was discovered "lying dead upon a golden couch dressed in her royal robes. Of her two women, Iras lay dying at her feet, while Charmion, already tottering and scarcely able to hold up her head, was adjusting the crown which encircled her mistress's brow."
Now we come to the hard part-trying to decide how much of this romantically tragic ending is true? The reason being is that propaganda and some things not considered by historians and commentators. Maybe the queen's leaving the stage was in Octavian's interest? Executing a woman was not fashionable in Rome, and Cleopatra's appearance at his triumph in Rome might not have been the glittering prize it would first seem to be.
Octavian could well have remembered how Cleopatra's half-sister, Arsinoe, had won the onlookers sympathy when led in chains in one of Julius Caesar's triumphs. Could it not have been much to Octavian's advantage to have Cleopatra kill herself? Here is one scenario: When Cleopatra didn't show any tendencies toward suicide, Dolabella, a man probably half the queen's age and far from being the type of trustworthy and loyal servant that the aforementioned Iras and Charmion were, was instructed to put a "bug" in Cleopatra's ear and leak his employer's travel plans in the hope that this would push her over the edge-and it did.
As for the exact way Cleopatra exited this life it is best to agree with Dio's judgment that "no one knows clearly in what way she perished." First of all the story of the asp in a basket of figs is problematic. The typical size of such a reptile would be eight feet long-a bit large for a basket of figs and one would assume very difficult to handle! Secondly, a single bite by an asp is not necessarily fatal, and even when it is, as much as two hours can pass before the victim of the bite perishes.
We can suppose that Octavian arranged to have Cleopatra murdered, and had his propaganda machine crank out the suicide story. The problem with this theory is that there is absolutely no evidence for it. We can only judge from the facts and aftermath of the queen's death. A second look has shown us that it might have been much to Octavian's advantage to have the queen out of the way-somehow-as she would probably not have been the centerpiece of any triumph he would hold in Rome.
Octavian certainly showed no hesitation whatsoever in have the boys Caesarion and Antyllus caught and executed. Sadly, the boys' last big celebration-their coming of age ceremony was also their death sentence, for it made them as qualified for blame as culpable adults. The younger children, the twins Alexander Helios and Cleopatra Selene, and Ptolemy Philadelphus, were spared. Some historians apparently have questions about whether the youngest-Ptolemy Philadelphus- survived the journey to Rome. After being in Octavian's triumph, they joined a large group of children being cared for by Octavian's sister-the kind and maternal Octavia.
When Cleopatra Selene had grown up, she married the scholarly King Juba of Numidia, by whom she had a son and a daughter. In all likelihood, she took her brothers with her to North Africa. History tells us nothing more about them and we can suppose that they led intentionally quiet lives-doing all they could to avoid Rome's dangerous and unfair spotlight.
Octavian was somewhat different from many Romans-he enjoyed being a tourist but didn't loot expensive and beautiful objects. He only took one item, a single agate cup, away from the palace of the Ptolemies. He visited some of the sights in Alexandria, which would have been exquisite and brilliant in white limestone and marble. The most important of the sites to Octavian especially was the tomb of Alexander the Great, which stood at the crossroads of the city's two main avenues. Alexander had died in 323 BC. His embalmed body was placed in a gold and crystal coffin and was the new city's most sacred monument. Today, not a trace of the corpse or the building that housed it, the Soma, remains, although it very well could have stood on the site of today's Mosque of the Prophet Daniel.
Octavian was now the same age-33-as Alexander when he died. He was a great devotee of the conquering Macedonian. Octavian wanted to see the mummy and honor it; so it was temporarily removed from its coffin and burial chamber and displayed to the public.
The image is just an example of some Roman coinage. I almost got all the way caught up tonight-and just couldn't quite make it to the end. I will now need some time to get some article-sized information written. If tonight turns out to be another night of insomnia, I might even be able to work a bit on it this eve/am-but I would really like to sleep for once! I may be offline tomorrow-but do hope to be back soon. Again I appreciate the wonderful and insightful comments so much from Jon and others who have commented!
Hi Devin,
ReplyDeleteGreat job on these last two posts... you have a flair for the intrigue of this complex history, and tell it so well... thanks!
I am also skeptical about the whole asp in the fig basket scenario, and in cases like this am prone to apply Ackham's Razor. The simplest explanation (Octavian had her killed) seems the most plausible and expedient. Either way, he was such a tactful operator she probably envisioned some terrible future and devious plans to humiliate her and would, perhaps have welcomed death as the better alternative... somehow it's all a bit sad all the same.
But that's an interesting detail about Octavian having Alexander removed from the tomb and put on display. Actually, that's just damn strange!
Thanks again for these posts... it's been a fun journey so far, and I hope you keep this going.
Hope that you're feeling well, that the cat isn't being too much of a pain in the ass, and that the internet connection holds.
jp
Jon-as I have said before -I am delighted that you are enjoying these posts and commenting!!
ReplyDeleteI am really getting into my love of historical subjects again and hope to keep this blog going at a certain pace and hopefully to never have those 2 month vacancies in posting again
I should actually have a post for today-well not should-will as long as back and all stay good enough to stay online
the next days after this will be a bit different as my disability hearing is the 17th -and i also have to (well dont have to but should if i want to get up on time!) more or less stay up thru the eve til the morning of the 18th to pick up my food box -especially as i dont drive anymore and mom will be taking me -man that poor woman -i dont know what i'd do without her and she is logging "mega miles" on her car just to help me out with all of this stuff!!!
I dont know if i will do MFM first today or this first but something should be here in a matter of hours
and i hope to have time today to get around to friends' blogs including you if you have updated
all the best in the world to you my friend and again thanks so very much for your comments!!
hopefully after this week is over and done i can get back on track posting !!
Jon-haha -forgot to say-my moggy is fine today -haha she gets "wet food" instead of dry every few days or so and considers this a delicacy :-)
ReplyDeleteand she is so tiny (eight pounds) i split each can -and today and was the second wet food day so she is quite approving of me:-) right now
all the best!!!
The truth is in the pudding
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGi2XwzLHHg
Eric thanks also for your comment -I cannot get used to having things not go to moderation first and keep missing commnents -I will check the video out in a minute -thanks again!!
ReplyDeleteJon I also forgot to mention that I also thought the thing about Octavian "honoring" the corpse of Alex the great was a bit strange-spooky-can't wait to see what you think about the "nose" incident unless you already knew about it !!
all the best!!